Learn

Why above 4 inches differs from 4 or more

"Above 4 inches" means more than 4 inches. A total of exactly 4.0 inches does not count. On Kalshi, the label you see on a contract is short; the rule underneath says exactly which comparison...

A silhouetted person beside a rising line of light that crosses a glowing horizontal threshold line on a dark blue wall.

Short answer

"Above 4 inches" means more than 4 inches. A total of exactly 4.0 inches does not count. On Kalshi, the label you see on a contract is short; the rule underneath says exactly which comparison applies, and the edge case is where traders get caught.

What does "above" mean in a Kalshi weather market?

Take New York City's December 2026 snow market. The contract labeled "Above 4 inches" has this rule: "If the total snowfall in New York City in December 2026 is strictly greater than 4 inches, then the market resolves to Yes." Strictly greater than means equality fails. If the December total were exactly 4.0 inches, that contract would resolve No.

The same market lists other cutoffs, such as Above 2 inches and Above 6 inches, each with the same "strictly greater than" wording. The Weather Company is the named source.

Rain works the same way. Kalshi's Los Angeles market for November 2026 resolves Yes "if the total precipitation at CLILAX in Los Angeles in Nov 2026 is strictly greater than 1 inches." A month that ends at exactly 1.00 inch is not above 1 inch.

Why do temperature bands read differently?

Daily temperature markets split the range into bands instead of repeating one cutoff. In Kalshi's New York City daily high market for November 12, 2026, the bands run from "58° or below" to "67° or above," with two-degree bands such as "59° to 60°" in between.

The labels and the rules use different words for the same idea. The "58° or below" band resolves Yes if the high is "less than 59°." The "67° or above" band resolves Yes if the high is "greater than 66°." A middle band like "59° to 60°" resolves Yes if the high is "between 59-60°." Each daily high lands in exactly one band, and the rule text, not the label, is what counts at settlement. The station is New York City (CLINYC), and the source is The Weather Company.

How do you avoid the edge-case mistake?

Read the rule, not just the label. Three things decide the outcome: the comparison word (strictly greater than, less than, between), the number, and the measurement it applies to, meaning the station, the period and the named source. A snow total, a monthly rain total and a single day's high are different measurements, even in the same city.

Kalshi's weather rules also warn that preliminary readings can change. Resolution uses the official value the rules name, so a number you saw early in the day is not the settled figure. For how stations and sources work, see how weather prediction markets work.

Kalshi (opens in a new tab) (Trade $25 Get $25), code WINPREDITCS. 21+. Terms apply, see below.

Sources

  • Kalshi, "Snow in New York City in Dec 2026?" market rules (kalshi.com), read November 11, 2026.
  • Kalshi, "Rain in Los Angeles in Nov 2026?" market rules (kalshi.com), read November 11, 2026.
  • Kalshi, "Highest temperature in New York City on Nov 12, 2026?" market rules (kalshi.com), read November 11, 2026.

21+. Trading involves risk.

Frequently asked questions

Does exactly 4 inches count as above 4 inches on Kalshi?

No. Kalshi's NYC snow rule says "strictly greater than 4 inches," so exactly 4.0 inches resolves the Above 4 inches contract No.

Is "above" the same as "4 or more"?

No. "Above 4" excludes 4 itself. "4 or more" would include it. Kalshi's snow and rain cutoffs use "strictly greater than."

What does "67° or above" mean in Kalshi's NYC temperature market?

The rule for that band says the day's high must be "greater than 66°" Fahrenheit at CLINYC, according to The Weather Company.

Where do I find the exact threshold rule?

In each contract's rules on the exchange. The rule names the comparison, the number, the station or area, the period and the data source.

One useful prediction-market lesson a week

Plain-English tips, new guides and offer changes. No spam.